Pinoy Eh! Online

Letters for the Editor - September 2007

Home
Article Page
Features
News Reports
Photo Album Page
Mailbag
Contact Us
Editorial
Archives
Pinoy Newstand
Organizations

Volume 6 - Issue #4
Pinoy Eh! Online Edition
September 2007

Letters to the Editor - September 2007

Re: Pinoy Eh Editorial

Your Editorial in the last issue of Pinoy,Eh! flayed Fr. Arana, the spiritual leader of the Filipino community for many years, indiscreetly. I found that piece of journalism repugnant, insolent and no taste at all. This kind of character assassination should not continue with impunity, in a united community like ours.

I believe that the issue resulted from PCC’s relentless pursuit to have a community centre realized at the expense of his credibility. I feel that whatever Fr. Arana has done, it probably was due to memory lapses, something unintentional,yet he was vilified by those mawkish desperados.

Fr. Arana is as human as anybody else in this community of so-called Christians who are supposed to be understanding and forgiving, and lest we forget, he is not infallible and neither is he a paragon of virtue .

The Editorial alluded to the misconception that the community had been awaiting the results of PCC’s offer to lease the convent...something which has always been talked about yet nothing has been recorded as to the actual desire of the community to have a center..of course, it would be nice to have our own center as most Filipino communities in the surrounding cities have, but not to the extent of brazenly critisizing some of our leaders if our desires are not realized..

The community center in Tampa, Florida, is a beautiful piece of architecture. It was finally realized after more than fifteen years of sacrifices by the leaders of the community...I can appreciate the time and effort that our leaders are doing to have this dream come true but time is imminent..though at this time I feel it is far-fetched, hopefully, a community centre would someday arise in our surroundings.. that centre in Tampa was originally a swamp area, minus crocodiles, which was solidified by all hands who availed themselves..the same is true in Ottawa, where our leaders are trying their best to have it realized but not any sooner than we want to..

So, we should stop bickering and criticizing people if our desires are not immediately met..obviously, this is inherent as part of our culture where we have internalized the habit of blaming ang criticizing each other instead of supporting and uniting together..it has been part and parcel of subjugation we tendered to from since the time of colonialism..let us examine and be true to ourselves..we tend to blame and criticize one another but why is it that we cannot argue when we deal with white people..how is it that we cannot dispute, we cannot argue, we cannot bargain, nor negotiate with them...how is it that we always bow down and say amen to them yet we tend to quarrel with our kababayans...my friends, it is not the end of the world yet and maybe it would be a better tomorrow if we just wait...our impatience has only exacerbated an already corroded irreverence to a leader of so many years now..

Flavio Gomez, September 4, 2007

*********************************************

The editorial referred to by Mr. Gomez does not criticize the hard-working leaders of this community. It simply denounces Fr. Arana ‘s handling of what now seems to be a poisoned "lease offer" of the Assumption convent. The blatant disregard of the will and hardwork of the community leaders involved in the ‘offer’ had to be put into perspective. Honest, selfless and hardworking community leaders’ effort to serve their kabayans should be rewarded and not brushed aside.

Unfortunately, Mr. Gomez, in his attempt to come to the succor of Fr. Arana seems out-of-touch. As if PCC wrote the editorial, he accuses PCC of vilifying Fr. Arana because of its "relentless pursuit to have a community centre realized" which in the first place, according to him, is a "misconception" because it is "something which has always been talked about yet nothing has been recorded as to the actual desire of the community to have a center."

Founded over eight years ago by some of the community’s well-respected leaders, PCC has been front and centre of the initiative to build a community centre to serve the growing Filipino-Canadian community in Ottawa. Raffles and other funding drive projects that have been supported by hundreds if not thousands of our community members have been held raising the significant amount that PCC has now in its bank account as community fund. Yet, the person writes that this community does not want such a community centre?

Not content in calling PCC mawkish desperados, in pontifical fashion, Mr. Gomez castigates the Filipino, flogs his very own people for its ‘subjugation’ by the ‘puti’ colonizers from the likes of whom he says "we cannot dispute, we cannot argue, we cannot bargain nor negotiate with". How in the gallant history of the Filipinos did the likes of Andres Bonifacio and Gabriela Silang figure eminently as shining examples of how the short, brown man who wielded nothing more than a ‘bolo’ stood up and fought the ‘puti ‘ of the letter-writer.

Here is the typical example of the notorious ‘alimango’ of the Filipino society. Not only does he not support his community leaders’ efforts to serve this community, he even chastises them if not outright ridiculing their effort.

EDs

Re: PINOY EH! VOL. 6 # 3 PAGE 2 : " Regarding prayers and shams,…etc."

I was surprised to read this unsigned article regarding Father Pedro Arana and the Assumption Convent. Presumably this is an editorial and therefore the opinion of the editors? No amount of angry rhetoric can disguise the absence of substantial facts in this argument. I guess, with difficulty, given the hyperbole of the text, that what is at issue is the possibility of leasing the convent from the Grey Nuns, and a letter of offer prepared by the PCC (Philippine Centre Canada). It seems that a letter was "finalized for Father Arana’s signature", but that Father Arana thought it should be re-written. Before the reader is asked to pass judgement on this event, could the letter in question not have been published in PINOY EH? Any arrogance here is on the part of the writer of the "editorial" ---who seems to think that is the "duty" of the pastor of Assumption parish to obediently sign his name to a letter drafted by the PCC. Why was this letter not signed by its president? I applaud Father Pedro’s courage in remaining true to his calling as the Roman Catholic pastor of Assumption parish, and not stooping to be the puppet of a partisan group, even if he is of the same nationality. I sadly suspect he may have had to deal with such ignorant bullying back in his native land.

Elizabeth Krug , August 8, 2007

****************************************************

Ms. Krug is known to us as a very conscientious researcher. She has done a number of excellent researches and presentations for St. Brigid’s Parish where Fr. Arana served as her parish priest for 10 years. So while she was surprised to read the editorial, we were likewise surprised to read an email from her without her usual diligence in checking on the issue beforehand. We assumed that she was showed only the editorial without the relevant articles in Pinoy Eh about the subject. That explains her seemingly confused grasp of the issue when she wrote the letter to the editors. Pinoy Eh directed Ms. Krug to check out the repository of information at www.pinoyeh.com/fcc as culled by Pinoy Eh and Tinig Pinoy about the Assumption Convent issue.

After Ms. Krug checked on the references and the other relevant information we provided, her suggestion was for Pinoy Eh, (being the organizer of the community meetings) and Ms. Sonia del Rosario with Ms. Tessie Morin representing PCC, Philippine Centre Canada, (being endorsed by Fr. Arana to present the business plan) to speak with Msgr. Kevin Beach directly. It was Msgr. Beach, the Vicar General, who endorsed the generous offer of the Grey Nuns to Fr. Arana. We responded to Ms. Krug by saying that Pinoy Eh has considered the case closed. Sometime in July, we were informed that Sister Nora of the Grey Nuns talked to Ms. Sonia del Rosario, PCC chair. Sister Nora explained that the Assumption Convent was NEVER meant for the Filipino Community. It was meant for Assumption Parish ONLY. So all this talk of having the Assumption Convent open to all Filipinos irregardless of faith or religion (as explained in the community meetings) are all wrong assumptions. We regret that a lot of people (Ambassador Brillantes, Consul General Angeles, Consul Rodriguez and all the 25 Filipino leaders) were inconvenienced and a lot of community effort was put into this whole issue. Pinoy Eh and Tinig Pinoy were led to organize the community by this false hope of community spirit for all Filipinos in an Assumption Convent property.

Fr. Arana have also considered the issue closed as of June 16 when Pinoy Eh’s editor-in-chief tried to clear up the issue with him. Fr. Arana at that time mentioned about a letter sent by Sister Nora dated April 3 rd in response to his letter of endorsement (of PCC to present the business plan to the Grey Nuns). This letter was NEVER known to ANYONE before June except to Fr. Arana. The said letter, Fr. Arana further explained is not meant for publication (although photocopies of the letter proliferated after the June issue of Pinoy Eh was released). It was Fr. Arana’s wish then that the whole issue be left behind, not to be discussed in the future and to move on. Fr. Arana said and we quote him "If I will be asked about this issue, we will just talk about it in a joke."

There was another letter to the editor received by Pinoy Eh. Mr. Mel Tabalba sent it in June but later withdrew it in deference to Fr. Arana’s wishes. Mr. Gomez and Ms. Krug chose to have their letter published.

We leave it to any other people who may wish to know about this issue to just check out the website http://www.pinoyeh.com/fcc.

CASE CLOSED. EDs

Ottawa, Ontario CANADA

Feedback, submissions, ideas? Email editorial@pinoyeh.com